Case Study: Speaking with One Voice, Even When We Disagree

Good governance does not require board members to agree on everything. It requires them to deliberate thoughtfully, make decisions collectively, and respect the authority of the board as a whole.

The Case: A Difficult Financial Decision

A nonprofit organization has experienced a significant financial setback. Government funding for several programs has been discontinued, even though the community's need for those services remains strong.

The executive director informs the board that the organization cannot sustain its current level of services and staffing without additional revenue. The executive director and staff have explored alternative funding sources and achieved some success, but a substantial shortfall remains.

The executive director recommends discontinuing two programs and reducing staff to bring expenses into line with anticipated revenue. The recommendation is painful. Several employees have served the organization for many years, and the affected programs provide important services to vulnerable people.

During the board's deliberations, one member strongly opposes the recommendation. The member believes the organization has a responsibility to maintain services while continuing to seek replacement funding. The organization has financial reserves, and the member proposes using some of those reserves to sustain operations for another year.

Other board members question whether this approach would jeopardize the organization's long-term financial stability. They ask whether the reserves are sufficient, how much could safely be used, and what would happen if government funding were not restored.

The executive director explains the financial projections, the risks associated with continued deficits, and the consequences of delaying difficult decisions.

After considerable discussion, the board votes to approve the reductions. The dissenting member votes against the proposal but agrees with the other members that the board should communicate its decision with one voice.

However, following the meeting, the dissenting member contacts several employees, encourages them to oppose the layoffs, and suggests they seek legal representation and publicly challenge the board's decision.

The executive director brings these concerns to the board chair.

The dilemma: How should the board respond to a member who sincerely believes the organization has made a harmful decision but is now undermining the board's collective authority?

Adapted and expanded for educational purposes from "The Director's Dilemma," February 2019, by Julie Garland-McLellan, published through AltoPartners. Additional details concerning the executive director, financial reserves, and board deliberations have been introduced to explore the governance questions more fully.

Examining the Case Through a Carver Governance Lens

The Carver Policy Governance model offers a useful framework for examining this situation. It helps distinguish the responsibilities of the board from those of the executive director and clarifies how individual board members exercise their authority.

1. Ends and Means: What Is the Board Trying to Accomplish?

In Carver governance, the board's primary responsibility is to define the organization's Ends: the benefits to be produced, for whom, and at what worth or relative priority.

Programs, staffing arrangements, and service delivery methods are generally means used to accomplish those Ends.

The central governance question is not necessarily whether two particular programs should continue. It is whether the organization can continue achieving its intended results for the people it serves within acceptable financial and ethical boundaries.

The board should ask whether its Ends policies adequately express the results that matter most and whether its financial policies establish appropriate limits on the risks the executive director may take.

2. Board and Executive Director Responsibilities: Who Decides?

Under Carver governance, the board establishes the organization's Ends and the boundaries within which the executive director may operate. Within those boundaries, the executive director has the authority to select the means for achieving the Ends.

This raises an important question about our case:

Should the board have voted on specific program closures and staffing reductions at all?

Unless board policy reserves these decisions for the board, they would ordinarily fall within the executive director's delegated authority.

The board's responsibility would be to ensure that its policies adequately address financial sustainability, protection of organizational assets, treatment of employees, and achievement of the organization's Ends.

The executive director would then determine how best to respond to the funding shortfall while remaining within those policies.

This distinction does not diminish the board's responsibility. It makes the board accountable for establishing clear expectations and monitoring whether those expectations are being met.

3. Speaking with One Voice: How Does the Board Exercise Its Authority?

One of Carver's central principles is that the board exercises its authority collectively, not through individual members.

Board members should be encouraged to question assumptions, challenge recommendations, offer alternatives, and express disagreement during deliberations.

Indeed, thoughtful disagreement can improve the quality of board decisions.

However, once the board has made a legitimate decision, individual members do not have independent authority to direct the executive director or employees, reverse the decision, or represent their personal views as the board's position.

Speaking with one voice does not mean thinking with one mind. It means exercising governance authority as one body.

A dissenting member may continue to believe the decision was mistaken. The member can request that the board reconsider the issue through its established processes. But encouraging employees to resist the decision crosses the boundary between governance and management.

This principle does not require silence about unlawful conduct or prevent a board member from fulfilling legitimate legal and fiduciary responsibilities.

4. Monitoring Without Micromanaging: How Does the Board Know?

The board has a legitimate responsibility to understand whether the organization is financially sustainable and whether its Ends are being achieved.

In this case, the board might request monitoring information showing:

  • The projected operating deficit and available financial reserves.

  • The executive director's interpretation of applicable financial policies.

  • The financial consequences of alternative approaches.

  • The anticipated effect of program reductions on achievement of the Ends.

  • Evidence that the executive director's decisions remain within established policy boundaries.

The purpose of monitoring is not to substitute the board's operational judgment for that of the executive director. It is to determine whether the organization is achieving its Ends and operating within the limitations established by the board.

The Four Categories of Carver Governance Policies

This case illustrates how the four categories of Policy Governance work together.

Policy Category

Application to the Case

Ends

What results must the organization achieve, for whom, and at what worth?

Executive Limitations

What financial risks, uses of reserves, and treatment of employees would be unacceptable?

Board–Management Delegation

What authority has the board delegated to the executive director, and how will performance be monitored?

Governance Process

How will board members deliberate, make decisions, speak collectively, and fulfill their governance responsibilities?

The purpose of these policies is not to anticipate every difficult situation. It is to establish a framework that allows the board and executive director to exercise their respective responsibilities with clarity and accountability.

What Would Effective Governance Look Like?

An effective board would create an environment in which members feel both inspired by the organization's purpose and safe to express differing perspectives.

Before making a decision, the board would welcome questions, examine relevant evidence, consider alternatives, and ensure that the executive director's reasoning is understood.

It would also respect the distinction between setting policy and managing operations.

After making a decision, the board would honor its collective authority, communicate through authorized channels, and monitor results.

If a member believed the decision threatened the organization's mission or violated its policies, that member would bring the concern back to the board rather than attempting to exercise authority independently.

In our case, the board chair should first seek to understand the dissenting member's concerns and verify what occurred. The chair could then clarify the member's governance responsibilities and explore how the concerns could be addressed through the board's established processes.

The goal should be to restore effective governance, not simply to suppress disagreement.

Questions for Reflection and Discussion

  1. Was the board exercising appropriate governance authority when it voted on specific program closures and layoffs, or should those decisions have been left to the executive director?

  2. What information about financial reserves and future funding would help the board evaluate whether its financial policies were adequate?

  3. How can board members express strong disagreement while respecting the collective authority of the board?

  4. What should a board member do when convinced that a decision will harm the organization or the people it serves?

  5. Do CBEL's existing policies adequately address communication with employees, public statements, confidentiality, and the authority of individual board members?

  6. What information should CBEL's board monitor to assure itself that the organization is achieving its Ends without becoming involved in operational decisions?

Governance in Today's World

Email, text messages, and social media make it easier than ever for individual board members to express their views publicly. They also make it easier for personal opinions to be mistaken for official organizational positions.

Clear governance policies help board members understand when they are speaking as individuals and when they are authorized to represent the organization.

The greater challenge, however, is cultivating a board culture in which members can disagree openly, listen respectfully, and remain committed to their shared responsibility.

The art of governance is learning to think independently while acting collectively. The discipline of governance is respecting the boundaries of our authority, especially when we disagree.

Source: Adapted from Julie Garland-McLellan, "The Director's Dilemma," February 2019, AltoPartners. The scenario has been expanded and interpreted through the principles of John Carver's Policy Governance model for educational discussion.

Previous
Previous

Strength of Character & Compassion

Next
Next

Executive Director’s Update